Q*
In plain wordsThe code name of an internal OpenAI research project, reported in late 2023, said to let AI solve math problems it had never seen. Later reports linked it to OpenAI's first reasoning model, o1.
- 1
OpenAI project
The reported code name of an internal OpenAIOpenAI, prop. n.: The American company that makes ChatGPT and the GPT models. It began in 2015 as a nonprofit research lab and is now a for-profit company overseen by a nonprofit foundation. research effort that became public in November 2023, days after the board's brief removal of chief executive Sam AltmanSam Altman, prop. n.: An American entrepreneur who co-founded OpenAI and runs it; the company's 2022 release of ChatGPT turned him into one of the public faces of the AI era.. Reuters reported that some staff had written to the board warning of a powerful discovery, citing a model called Q* that could solve grade-school mathematics problems it had not seen before, and that the letter was one of several factors behind the firing; The Verge, citing a person familiar with the matter, reported that the board never received such a letter. The Information described Q* as building on work by Ilya SutskeverIlya Sutskever, prop. n.: A Russian-born Israeli-Canadian computer scientist who co-built the AlexNet image recognizer, helped found OpenAI and lead its research until 2024, and now heads the startup Safe Superintelligence Inc. and developed by Jakub Pachocki and Szymon Sidor, using computer-generated data and extra computation to improve reasoning. According to Reuters, OpenAI acknowledged the project in an internal message to staff, but it has never published a technical account; Altman called the reports an 'unfortunate leak'. In July 2024 Reuters reported that the work continued under the code name Strawberry, which was widely identified with OpenAI o1OpenAI o1, prop. n.: OpenAI's first reasoning model, from 2024. Before replying it writes out a long, hidden series of steps, trying ideas and checking them, which lifted its scores on hard math, science and coding problems far above earlier chatbots'. on its release in September 2024.
In hindsight, the Q* leak was the first public hint that OpenAI was betting on reasoning at inference time.
- 2
Reinforcement learning
Standard notation for the optimal action-value function: the expected discounted return from taking action a in state s and acting optimally afterward. It satisfies the Bellman optimality equationBellman equation, n.: A rule saying that how good a situation is equals the reward you get now plus how good the next situation is, slightly discounted — so long-term planning can be solved one step at a time., and Q-learningQ-learning, n.: A trial-and-error method in which an agent keeps a score for every move in every situation and nudges each score toward the reward it got plus the best score available next. estimates it from experience; an agent that knows Q* acts optimally by always choosing the action with the highest value.
Origin
The project name was first reported on 22–23 November 2023 by Reuters and The Information, amid the turmoil over Altman's dismissal and reinstatement; Reuters connected it to Strawberry in July 2024. Commentators speculated that the name combines Q*, the reinforcement-learning symbol, with A* searchA* search, n.: A method for finding the shortest route on a map or network that weighs both how far you have already come and a smart guess of how far is left, so it tries the most promising paths first., a reading OpenAI never confirmed. The notation Q* is far older, standard since Christopher Watkins's work on Q-learning (1989).
Usage note
Much public discussion of Q* was speculation, including claims that it signaled imminent artificial general intelligenceartificial general intelligence, n.: AI that could learn and do almost any mental task a capable adult can, rather than excelling at one narrow job. Experts disagree on the exact bar and on when, or whether, it will arrive.; details beyond the reporting summarized here are unconfirmed. The episode is often cited as an example of hype around unpublished breakthroughs.
Related
- OpenAI o1OpenAI o1, prop. n.: OpenAI's first reasoning model, from 2024. Before replying it writes out a long, hidden series of steps, trying ideas and checking them, which lifted its scores on hard math, science and coding problems far above earlier chatbots'.
- OpenAIOpenAI, prop. n.: The American company that makes ChatGPT and the GPT models. It began in 2015 as a nonprofit research lab and is now a for-profit company overseen by a nonprofit foundation.
- reasoning modelreasoning model, n.: An AI model trained to work through a problem step by step in hidden 'thinking' text before it answers. Letting it think longer generally makes it better at math, coding and planning.
- test-time computetest-time compute, n.: The computing effort an AI model spends while answering a question, as opposed to while being trained. Letting a model think longer or try many answers can make it markedly smarter.
- Q-learningQ-learning, n.: A trial-and-error method in which an agent keeps a score for every move in every situation and nudges each score toward the reward it got plus the best score available next.
- Sam AltmanSam Altman, prop. n.: An American entrepreneur who co-founded OpenAI and runs it; the company's 2022 release of ChatGPT turned him into one of the public faces of the AI era.
- Ilya SutskeverIlya Sutskever, prop. n.: A Russian-born Israeli-Canadian computer scientist who co-built the AlexNet image recognizer, helped found OpenAI and lead its research until 2024, and now heads the startup Safe Superintelligence Inc.
Sources
- Tong, A., Dastin, J. & Hu, K. (2023). OpenAI researchers warned board of AI breakthrough ahead of CEO ouster, sources say. Reuters, 22 November 2023.
- Tong, A. & Paul, K. (2024). Exclusive: OpenAI working on new reasoning technology under code name 'Strawberry'. Reuters, July 2024.
Mentioned in
OpenAI o1OpenAI o1, prop. n.: OpenAI's first reasoning model, from 2024. Before replying it writes out a long, hidden series of steps, trying ideas and checking them, which lifted its scores on hard math, science and coding problems far above earlier chatbots'.